Animal Crossing Villager Popularity and Value List by Tier 2020

This list is sourced from Animal Crossing Portal as well as browsing discord and watching transactions take place.  The villagers are being exchanged for Nook Miles Tickets or Bells.

All values are subjective and based on supply and demand.  As of now, the two highest demanded Villagers are by far Raymond and Audie.  As more people become aware of these villagers, they will be kept more often and the rankings change.   Stay tuned for updates.

Whether popular or not, there are 6 new villagers that are impossible to get unless you grind out mystery items or get lucky.  The reason?  They are brand new with no way to bring them in game with an Amiibo card.  For that reason alone, the 6 new villagers are the most “rare” in game.

Raymond

Regardless of what various lists try to change to manipulate the animal crossing market, Raymond is by far the most valuable and sought after Villager in New Horizon.  There is no one even close.  Although Marshal is being pushed as top tier, he can be brought in the game in unlimited amounts via Amiibo so the supply is greater than the demand.

Judy

Again, without any way to get her other than grinding out mystery islands or getting lucking with a camp site visit, Judy’s demand far surpasses her supply.  Until the new villagers have an Amiibo card, they will remain the most sought after villagers in the game.  Although the die hard fans want so bad to push their old favorites above the list, it would be a farce to pretend any of the amiibo villagers come close in value to the fab 3 (Raymond / Judy / Audie).

Audie

Audie is the based off a real life grandmother (supposedly) than had over 3500 hours in new leaf.  However, judging the market, she seems to end up as a lot of players first 5 villagers.  Unsure if her RNG is slightly set in her favor to make sure players get her, but we rarely visit an island that does not have an audie.  And we visit a LOT of islands.

Sherb

Hit the scene hard and was extremely sought after until one day… no one wanted him.  Not part of the fab 3, but still a top tier villager that you can’t get through the Amiibo system at this time.

Cyd

As soon as his Amiibo drops he will quickly fall to tier 6.

Dom

Reneigh

Although rare, just not sought after.  The supply is still much greater than the demand, even if this villager can’t be brought in by Amiibo.

Megan

Cute, but not small.  The larger villagers tend to drop down tiers as the smaller cuter ones, tend to stay on top of most lists.  Megan is no exception to that rule.

 

No Amiibo available Tier 1

Tier 2 – Worth up to 5-10 Million Bells / 10 – 100 NMT max

Tier 3 – Worth up to 2-4 Million Bells / 5 – 25 NMT max

Tier 4 – Worth up to 1 Million Bells / 1-10 NMT max

Tier 5 – Worth up to 250,000 Bells / 2 NMT max (Alphabetical – Not Ranked)

Tier 6 – Often Giveaways (Alphabetical – Not Ranked)